Let's Talk Legal: Guardianship and the Less Restrictive Alternatives

May 20, 2025 | Cecil Harvell

Cecil Harvell and Wes Collins discussed guardianship laws, focusing on recent changes that emphasize the use of least restrictive alternatives (LRAs) before adjudicating someone as incompetent. They highlighted the importance of having a durable power of attorney in place to potentially avoid the need for guardianship, as well as the challenges families face when dealing with aging loved ones. The conversation also touched on the guardianship process for minors, emphasizing the need for proper planning to ensure the best interests of children are upheld.

Topic of Guardianship

  • The main focus of the discussion is guardianship, particularly recent changes in guardianship law related to "least restrictive means." This concept aims to ensure that guardianship is only pursued when absolutely necessary. [01:00]

Definition of Guardianship

  • Guardianship proceedings are initiated when a loved one can no longer care for themselves, either physically or financially. This includes situations where individuals may be at risk of harm due to neglecting medication or financial responsibilities. [02:00]

Durable Power of Attorney

  • A durable power of attorney is emphasized as a crucial tool that can prevent the need for guardianship. If the agent under the power of attorney acts appropriately, guardianship may not be necessary. [04:00]

Least Restrictive Alternatives (LRA)

  • The new standard in guardianship law is the consideration of least restrictive alternatives (LRA). This includes evaluating whether a power of attorney is in place and functioning effectively before determining if guardianship is needed. [05:00]

Changes in Legal Standards

  • Previously, the determination of incompetency was based primarily on medical evidence. The new law requires consideration of whether there are effective alternatives in place before adjudicating someone as incompetent. [08:00]

Scenarios Where Guardianship May Still Be Necessary

  • Several scenarios are discussed where guardianship may still be required despite having a power of attorney, such as when the principal is defiant or when the agent under the power of attorney is misusing their authority. [12:00]

Importance of Planning

  • The discussion highlights the importance of planning ahead, including having a power of attorney and other legal documents in place to minimize family conflict and stress in the event of incapacity. [16:00]

Guardianship for Minors

  • The conversation shifts to guardianship for minors, particularly in cases where parents pass away. The best interest of the child is the primary consideration, and having a designated guardian in a will can help avoid disputes. [20:00]

Listen Now
Let's Talk Legal: Guardianship and the Less Restrictive Alternatives
Cecil S. Harvell Martindale AV Rated
About the Author
Cecil S. Harvell is AV Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Rated in the areas of Trusts and Estates, General Practice, and Aged and Aging. Mr. Harvell is a native of Morehead City, North Carolina and was admitted to the Georgia State Bar in 1983 and admitted to the North Carolina State Bar in 1987. Inducted to The Order of the Long Leaf Pine. Read More

Wesley A. Collins Martindale AV Rated
Wesley A. Collins is AV Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Rated. Wesley A. Collins is a native of Kinston, North Carolina and was admitted to the North Carolina State Bar in 2000. Mr. Collins was admitted to the United States District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina in 2002. Mr. Collins is also a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum. Read More
Let's Talk Legal
See How Our Team Can Help You
GET IN TOUCH